Ontario’s Fault Determination Rules, every rule explained
Every rule your insurer uses to decide who was at fault, in plain English, with the split and a diagram. Link directly to any rule to cite it.
ONFaultChecker Editorial · Reviewed by a licensed Ontario claims adjusterUpdated August 3, 2026 · 5 min read · Sources: Insurance Act Reg. 668 · FSRA · Highway Traffic Act
Key takeaways
Ontario fault is assigned in fixed steps — 0%, 25%, 50%, 75% or 100%. Nothing in between.
Rule 3: weather, road conditions, visibility and where you were hit are all explicitly ignored.
Rule 4: if two rules fit, the one giving you the least fault applies — unless one says 100% and the other 0%, which becomes 50%.
Only two rules produce a 25/75 split; everything else is 0, 50 or 100.
You can ask your adjuster which rule number they applied. They should be able to tell you.
About this page
This is a plain-English restatement of R.R.O. 1990, Regulation 668 (Fault Determination Rules) under Ontario’s Insurance Act, last amended by O. Reg. 445/18. Every rule number and fault split here has been checked against the regulation. The wording is ours; the official text governs and is published free on Ontario’s e-Laws site.
This is general information, not legal advice. If a determination matters to you, raise the rule number with your adjuster or speak to a lawyer or paralegal.
Jump to a rule
Rules 1–5 are the framework. Rules 6–20 are the collision scenarios.
The centre line is whatever line is painted down the middle — single, double, solid or broken. If there is no painted line, it is the middle of the usable roadway, ignoring the parts blocked by parked cars, a snowbank or anything else obstructing traffic.
Your insurer is required to assess your degree of fault using this regulation. The diagrams published with it are illustrations only — they do not add to or limit what the written rules say.
Weather, road conditions and where you were hit are irrelevant
Fault is decided without reference to the circumstances of the incident — weather, road conditions, visibility, or what pedestrians did — and without reference to where on your vehicle the contact happened. This is the rule people find hardest to accept: “it was icy” and “they hit me on the side” do not change the determination.
The rule most favourable to you wins — with one exception
If more than one rule fits, the one assigning you the least fault is treated as the only rule that applies. The exception: in a two-vehicle incident, if one rule makes you 100% at fault and another makes you 0%, you are deemed 50% at fault.
If the incident is not described anywhere in the regulation, or there is not enough information to apply a rule, fault is determined under the ordinary rules of law instead.
Rear-ended while turning into a side road or driveway
If the front vehicle was turning right or left to enter a side road, private road or driveway, the front driver is still not at fault. The rear driver carries all of it.
If the front vehicle was moving forward into a parking place on either side of the road, the front driver is not at fault and the rear driver is fully at fault.
Every collision between two vehicles in the chain is assessed on its own, without reference to the other impacts. This is why one driver can be not at fault for the car in front and fully at fault for the car behind.
With A leading, B second and C third and all in motion: between A and B, A is not at fault and B is 50% at fault. Between B and C, B is not at fault and C is entirely at fault.
Left turn at an intersection while being overtaken
If A was turning left at an intersection and B was overtaking to pass, A is 25% at fault and B is 75% at fault. This is one of only two places the regulation uses a 25/75 split.
A collision on a parking lot thoroughfare — a main route into, through or out of the lot — is assessed using the rest of this regulation as though the thoroughfare were a road.
If A leaves a feeder lane and fails to yield to B on a thoroughfare, A is entirely at fault. A feeder lane is any parking lot road that is not a thoroughfare.
If A was illegally parked, stopped or standing when struck, and the incident happened outside a city, town or village, A is entirely at fault and B is not. Note the geographic limit — this reversal does not apply within a municipality.
A driver is entirely at fault if the collision happens while they fail to obey a police officer’s direction, a do-not-enter sign, a prohibited passing sign or a prohibited turn sign.
A driver is entirely at fault for a collision that happens while backing up, while making a U-turn, or when the driver or a passenger opens a door or leaves one open. This last one covers dooring a cyclist or a passing vehicle.
For this regulation a driver is considered charged with a driving offence if, as a result of the incident, they are charged with impaired operation by alcohol or a drug, driving over the legal blood alcohol limit, an indictable offence related to operating the vehicle, failing or refusing to provide a breath sample, or exceeding the speed limit by 16 km/h or more.
When a charge takes the incident out of these rules
If the driver of A is charged with one of those offences and the driver of B is wholly or partly at fault under these rules, fault is determined under the ordinary rules of law instead of this regulation.
Your insurer matches the facts of your collision to a scenario in this regulation and assigns the resulting percentage. It is a matching exercise, not a judgement call, which is why two adjusters should reach the same answer on the same facts.
Fault is recorded in your claims history and, at 25% or more, can affect your premium. Some insurers rate from 25%; the Financial Services Regulatory Authority treats 50% or more as chargeable. If you disagree, ask which rule number was applied — that turns a vague disagreement into a checkable one.
If you think the wrong rule was applied
Ask for the rule number in writing. Then read it here and check the scenario against what happened.
Point to the mismatch, not the outcome. “Rule 10(4) assumes I changed lanes; I did not” is far stronger than “that is unfair”.
Escalate in order — adjuster, supervisor, the insurer’s complaints officer, then the General Insurance OmbudService.
Evidence that moves rules: dashcam, an independent witness, the collision report, and photographs of final positions.
The fault calculator takes a description of what happened and matches it to a scenario, then estimates what the resulting fault percentage does to your renewal.
Where can I read the official Fault Determination Rules?
The authoritative version is R.R.O. 1990, Regulation 668 under the Insurance Act, published on Ontario's e-Laws website. This page sets out every rule in plain English with the rule number and the fault split so you can find and cite the one that applies, but the official wording governs. The regulation was last amended by O. Reg. 445/18, effective October 2018.
Can I cite a specific rule from this page?
Yes, that is what this page is for. Every rule and subsection has its own permanent anchor, and the 'Link to this rule' button copies a URL that opens the page scrolled to that exact rule with it highlighted. That makes it straightforward to reference a specific rule in a forum reply, a letter to an adjuster or an article.
Does weather or road condition change the fault determination?
No, and this is the provision people find hardest to accept. Rule 3 states that the degree of fault is determined without reference to the circumstances in which the incident occurred, including weather conditions, road conditions, visibility or the actions of pedestrians, and without reference to where on your vehicle the contact happened. Ice, fog and a blind corner do not change the rule that applies.
What if two rules seem to apply to my accident?
Rule 4 handles this. Where more than one rule applies, the rule that attributes the least degree of fault to you is treated as the only rule that applies. There is one exception: in a two-vehicle incident, if one rule would make you entirely at fault and another would make you not at fault, you are deemed 50 per cent at fault.
What happens if my accident is not in the rules at all?
Rule 5 covers it. If the incident is not described anywhere in the regulation, the degree of fault is determined in accordance with the ordinary rules of law. The same applies where there is insufficient information about the incident to apply a rule. In practice this is why unusual collisions take longer to resolve.
Next step
Check your own scenario
Describe what happened and see which rule applies and what it does to your premium.